Five social media giants failed to remove 84% of anti-Semitic posts in May and June – and Facebook fared the worst, despite announcing new rules to solve the problem, a new report said.
Driving the news: The Center for Countering Digital Hatred (CCDH) found in its study that it reported 714 posts with “anti-Jewish hatred” on Facebook, Twitter, Instagram, Youtube and TikTok – which were viewed a total of 7.3 million times. These “clearly violated” company guidelines, according to the CCDH.
- “Because they do not enforce their own rules, social media platforms like Facebook have become safe places to spread racism and propaganda against Jews,” says the report entitled “Failure to Act”.
According to the numbers: Facebook removed 14 of 129 reported posts (10.9%); Twitter removed 15 out of 137 reports (11%); TikTok removed 22 of 119 reported posts (18.5%); Instagram responded 52 out of 277 cases (18.8%) and YouTube pulled 11 of the 52 posts it was made aware of (21.2%).
Remarkable: “Extremist anti-Jewish hatred is not addressed: Platforms did not respond to 80% of the posts with Holocaust denial, 74% of the posts claiming blood libel, 70% of the racist caricatures of Jewish people and 70% of the neo-Nazi posts. according to a statement from the CCDH, a non-governmental organization based in the US and the UK.
- “Instagram, TikTok and Twitter allow hashtags for anti-Semitic content such as #rothschild, #fakejews and #killthejews, which were used in posts that were identified in our report and generated over 3.3 million impressions.”
The big picture: The report’s findings come despite social media giants having announced steps in recent months to tackle hate speech on their platforms.
- Facebook boss Mark Zuckerberg in particular announced last October that the tech giant would expand its hate speech guidelines to ban all content that “denies or distorts the Holocaust.”
What you say: A Facebook spokesperson said in a statement emailed that “in the face of the alarming rise in anti-Semitism around the world through our policies, we have and will continue to take significant action” by removing anti-Semitic posts “while we do the Educate people with relevant information about it ”.
- “These reports don’t take into account the fact that we have taken action against 15 times the amount of hate speech since 2017, the prevalence of hate speech on our platform is decreasing, and of the hate speech we remove, 97% were found before anyone was reported it to us, ”said the spokesman.
A YouTube spokesperson said in a statement emailed that the company values feedback from the CCDH and has put in place a “robust hate speech policy” that “makes significant strides in our ability to include hateful content that violates our community guidelines anti-Semitic content, to be removed quickly ”.
- YouTube has “removed over 85,000 videos that violate our hate speech guidelines,” as described in its report for the first quarter of 2021, “the spokesman added.
- Of the 52 videos rated by CCDH, YouTube removed 30 videos for violating its hate speech guidelines, 13 of which were removed, according to YouTube, before the nonprofit’s report was released. It also ended two channels.
A Twitter spokesperson said in an email to Axios that “improving the speed and level of our policy enforcement is a top priority for us.”
- “We recognize that there is more to be done and we will continue to listen and incorporate stakeholder feedback into these ongoing efforts,” added the spokesman.
- Representatives of the other companies named in the report did not immediately respond to the request for comments from Axios.
Read the full report on DocumentCloud:
Editor’s Note: This article has been updated with comments from Facebook and YouTube.